Soteriology · Scripture Evidence

The Scripture Evidence

The foundational passages of the discipline, each with the readings the doctrinal traditions give it. Every reading carries its doctrinal question, its argument, the position that makes it, and its sources. A passage is carried by reference only; no verse wording is stored or shown.

Genesis 3

Classical Calvinism

Read with Romans 5, the narrative is the historical fountainhead of the race's condition: Adam's disobedience is the act in which humanity stood, and its sentence, death, is the inheritance of his descendants. This reading grounds the doctrines of inherited corruption and imputed guilt in a real first transgression.

Work on this passage in the Workshop

Eastern Orthodox

The narrative tells of the ancestors' turning and its fruit: mortality enters, and the descendants inherit a wounded nature and death, not personal guilt for an act they did not commit. Salvation is therefore framed as healing and the gift of immortality, administered in the church's baptism.

Work on this passage in the Workshop

Romans 3:21-26

Lutheran

The passage is read as the charter of justification by faith alone: God declares the ungodly righteous as a gift, Christ set forth as the atoning sacrifice turns away wrath, and human boasting is excluded because the righteousness is received, not achieved.

Work on this passage in the Workshop

Catholic

The passage teaches that God's righteousness is given through faith and works its effect in the believer: the gift is neither earned nor a bare declaration, since the God who justifies also renews, and the faith through which the gift comes is the faith that works by love.

Work on this passage in the Workshop

Romans 5:12-21

Classical Calvinism

Paul's 'in whom all sinned,' in the Latin text Augustine read, teaches that all humanity was in Adam and shares his guilt as well as his corruption: the parallel with Christ's imputed righteousness requires a real imputation on the Adam side of the comparison.

Work on this passage in the Workshop

Eastern Orthodox

Paul teaches that death spread to all because all sinned: what passes from Adam is mortality, the condition in which personal sin becomes universal, rather than a verdict of guilt for another's deed. The Christ side of the parallel is then read as the gift of life healing the inherited condition.

Work on this passage in the Workshop

Romans 8:28-30

Classical Calvinism

The unbroken chain, foreknown, predestined, called, justified, glorified, with no link conditioned on the human subject, teaches that salvation rests from first to last on God's purpose: those God foreknew in love he carries to glory without loss.

Work on this passage in the Workshop

Classical Arminianism

Foreknowledge is read as God's knowing persons in covenant love beforehand, and the chain as the path of those who love God: the passage comforts believers with God's purpose without teaching that the purpose bypasses the faith it everywhere presupposes.

Work on this passage in the Workshop

Romans 9

Classical Calvinism

The chapter is read as direct teaching on individual election: Jacob and Esau before birth and before works, the potter's right over the clay, and mercy on whom God will have mercy together teach that the ultimate difference between saved and lost is God's unconditional choice.

Work on this passage in the Workshop

Classical Arminianism

The chapter is read within Paul's history of Israel: election in the chapter concerns the choice of peoples and persons for covenant service, Pharaoh's hardening a historical judgment within the story, and the potter image an echo of Jeremiah's conditional word to the nation.

Work on this passage in the Workshop

John 3:16

Wesleyan-Arminian

The verse is read at face value as the gospel's own summary of its scope: God's love embraces the world, the Son is given for it, and the only boundary of salvation is the believing the text itself names. No prior decree narrows what 'whoever believes' opens.

Work on this passage in the Workshop

Classical Calvinism

'World' is read by the design of the gift: God so loved the world that he gave his Son so that the believing ones, drawn from the world, should not perish. The verse's comfort is directed to believers, and its scope is expounded by the same Gospel's teaching that the Father gives a people to the Son who certainly come to him.

Work on this passage in the Workshop

John 6:37-44

Classical Calvinism

'All that the Father gives me will come to me' and 'no one can come unless the Father draws him' teach an effectual call: the drawing is not a bare invitation but the Father's gift of persons to the Son, who lose none of those given.

Work on this passage in the Workshop

Classical Arminianism

The drawing of the Father is read with John 12:32, where the lifted-up Son draws all people to himself: God's drawing is universal and resistible, as Israel's Scriptures and Jesus' own lament over Jerusalem show, and the 'given' are those who, drawn, come.

Work on this passage in the Workshop

John 10:27-29

Baptist and Evangelical

'My sheep hear my voice, and I give them eternal life, and they will never perish, and no one will snatch them out of my hand' is read as a settled promise: the believer's security rests on the Shepherd's keeping, and the true believer's final salvation is certain.

Work on this passage in the Workshop

Wesleyan-Arminian

The promise is read as spoken to the sheep as sheep: those who hear the Shepherd's voice and follow him are the ones no one snatches away. The security is real and it is the security of abiding; the passage promises keeping to followers, and its readers are warned elsewhere that branches that do not abide are cut off.

Work on this passage in the Workshop

Ephesians 1:3-14

Classical Calvinism

Chosen in Christ before the foundation of the world, predestined for adoption: the passage is read as the church's charter of unconditional election, blessing by blessing ascribed to God's purpose so that boasting is excluded from the first step to the last.

Work on this passage in the Workshop

Classical Arminianism

The blessings are 'in Christ' fourteen times over: God chose the body in its head before the world, and persons are elect as they are found in the Elect One by faith. Election is first of Christ and of the people in him, and individual participation follows incorporation.

Work on this passage in the Workshop

Ephesians 2:1-10

Classical Calvinism

Dead in trespasses, made alive together with Christ, seated with him: the passage is read as regeneration's classic text. The dead do not cooperate in their quickening; faith itself is carried inside the gift, 'and this is not your own doing.'

Work on this passage in the Workshop

Catholic

'By grace you have been saved through faith' is read as the economy of the whole sacramental life: grace is God's effective gift, received in faith and worked out in the good works prepared beforehand, so that salvation is gift at every stage and never a wage, yet never an inert possession.

Work on this passage in the Workshop

1 Timothy 2:3-6

Classical Arminianism

'Who will have all men to be saved' is read with its own scope: all men, without the restriction the opposing reading imports. The one mediator gave himself a ransom for all, and prayer for all, kings included, rests on a will for all.

Work on this passage in the Workshop

Classical Calvinism

'All' is read by its context as all classes: kings and all in authority are named because prayer had perhaps been restricted; the ransom is sufficient for all and the mediator one over all, while its saving application stands with those who come to the knowledge of the truth.

Work on this passage in the Workshop

2 Peter 3:9

Wesleyan-Arminian

'Not wishing that any should perish, but that all should come to repentance' is read as the stated heart of God's patience: the delay of the end is mercy at work, and the will it names is genuinely for the any and the all of its own sentence.

Work on this passage in the Workshop

Classical Calvinism

The patience is 'toward you': the letter's beloved addressees are the people of God, and the any who must not perish are read within that address, so the text teaches God's certain gathering of his own across the delay, read together with the chapter's own warning that the day will come like a thief.

Work on this passage in the Workshop

Hebrews 2:14-18

Classical Calvinism

He destroyed the one who holds the power of death and frees those held in slavery by fear: the passage is read within Christ's priestly mediation for Abraham's offspring, a definite people, whose high priest makes propitiation for their sins in particular.

Work on this passage in the Workshop

Eastern Orthodox

The passage is the charter of the victory and healing reading: by death Christ destroys the devil's hold, delivers the enslaved, and, having taken hold of Abraham's seed, heals the nature he assumed; the priestly propitiation stands inside this triumph, not beside it.

Work on this passage in the Workshop

1 John 2:1-2

Classical Arminianism

'He is the propitiation for our sins, and not for ours only but also for the sins of the whole world' is read as the extent question's plainest text: the apostle's own contrast is between the believing community and the whole world beyond it, and the propitiation is stated for both.

Work on this passage in the Workshop

Classical Calvinism

The verse is read with John's own usage: the world for which Christ is propitiation is the world of believers scattered among the nations, as in John 11:52, so the comfort runs to the church gathered from every people rather than to every person without exception.

Work on this passage in the Workshop

Revelation 20:11-15

Baptist and Evangelical

The great white throne judgment is read as the final assize of persons: the dead are judged by what is written in the books, according to what they had done, and the Book of Life decides the outcome; deeds are the evidence by which faith's reality or absence is disclosed before the world.

Work on this passage in the Workshop

Catholic

The passage is read within the church's whole doctrine of judgment: the general judgment manifests what the particular judgment at death has settled, the works in the books are the life of grace or its refusal made public, and the second death is the final loss of those whose names are not in the Lamb's book.

Work on this passage in the Workshop